Best Places to Eat in Florida Keys

Travel through the Florida Keys, and you'll find a foodie scene percolating in Islamorada, a group of six islands halfway between Miami and Key West.

Atlantic’s Edge

Lunch is at Atlantic’s Edge in the Cheeca Resort, where lingering in comfy bamboo chairs with your toes in the sand just steps from turquoise waters is encouraged. Watch sailboats in the distance and people fishing off the dock jutting into the Atlantic Ocean. Try the ahi ceviche, served chilled in a fresh half coconut, with spicy red peppers, green cilantro and sweet coconut sauce. Finish with New Zealand’s crisp Nobilo sauvignon blanc. Average entrée: $12.

cheeca lodge dining

Cheeca Lodge & Spa

Cheeca Pier Cheeca Lodge & Spa

Kaiyo Grill

Kaiyo Grill is the Caribbean-Asian go-to spot for uncommon catches like tripletail and tilefish as well as island-inspired sushi like the namesake roll with crispy tempura Florida lobster, mango, avocado and cilantro. Informal sake tastings take place at the long mahogany bar adorned with blue-hued mosaics. Start with the sweet, unfiltered Dreamy Clouds, and and then snack on warm naan bread fresh from his tandoori oven. Average entrée: $20.

sushi florida keys, where to eat florida keys
Don’t miss the the Macadamia Hogfish specialty roll with mango, pineapple and Jean’s Famous mango sauce.

Green Turtle Inn

Look for the iconic green neon sign that marks the Green Turtle Inn. Established in 1947, it’s still the locals’ “clubhouse” where musician Dave Feder revs up Friday evenings with his mixture of hillbilly and Flamenco style. The atmosphere is well matched by the Cajun touches added to the hearty turtle chowder (hence the restaurant’s name); pair it with an ice-cold Yuengling lager draft. Don’t miss the luscious seared scallops doused in truffle oil and sherry brown butter. Average entrée: $25.

florida keys where to eat, florida keys restaurants

The Green Turtle Inn

An Islamorada landmark since 1947. FTL